Besides a plate of cookies what do you give a male teacher? How about a car kit for cold winter days. My Grandma always kept a blanket and chocolate bar in her car in case she broke down and when I saw this blanket for $1.49 it made me think of that.
Blanket: Less than $2 at Menards or other stores
Candy bar: $.50 (bonus prize for anyone who guesses the name of the English chocolate I used!)
Final Cost: Mine was $2
Tie the blanket with some pretty ribbon and attach the candy bar and a candy cane. Add a note: “Keep in your car just in case. Thanks for everything!”